Skip to main content

How to Date a Shy Girl

  • Author:
  • Updated date:

Noelle is a shy girl here to share her tips and tricks for dating shy girls.

Tips for making a shy girl feel comfortable

Tips for making a shy girl feel comfortable

Dating a Shy Girl: How to Make a Shy Girl Comfortable

Getting to know someone who is shy can be a frustrating experience, especially if you don't know the reasons why that particular person is shy. In a dating situation, you may read the signs wrong or not be able to judge if she is actually into you or interested.

I've always been a shy girl myself, so below is some very good advice that I would give to people who would want to date a shy girl, as well as what has worked (and what hasn't) when someone was dating me.

Why Are People Shy?

Before you even consider dating a shy girl or befriending her, it's important to understand that people are shy for their own reasons.

Some girls are shy because they have had a bad experience in the past, such as getting bullied for being the "know-it-all" in class, while others learned from their parents to never talk unless spoken to. Some girls are also shyer around boys, especially if they've never had someone interested in them before.

Knowing that there are multiple reasons why people are shy will allow you to understand and be patient with the girl you're wanting to get to know (and potentially date). Being too straightforward and pushing her to talk will only make her feel pressured and less likely to feel comfortable around you.

The most important thing to remember is that it takes time for a shy person to open up and feel comfortable around someone new.

How to Make Her Feel Comfortable

The key to dating a girl who is shy is simply to make her feel comfortable. If you can make a girl comfortable around you, you're well on your way to being able to ask her out (or have her ask you out!)

Knowing a shy girl's interests can really help break the barrier.

Knowing a shy girl's interests can really help break the barrier.

Things that Will Make her Self-Conscious

  • Saying that she is shy will only make her more uncomfortable.
  • Pointing out that she doesn't talk much or trying too hard to make her talk will have the opposite effect. It actually makes the girl feel more pressured and nervous and will feel less comfortable around you.
  • Kissing in public or showing affection in public (at first especially)

Tips on Making a Shy Girl Comfortable Around You

One of the easiest and most effective ways to get a shy girl to be comfortable around you is to make her laugh and be goofy around her. Let her know that you're the biggest goofball between the two of you.

This will make her feel comfortable because she'll be able to forget how shy she is and let go of any pressure she feels in trying to make conversations or worrying if she's making a fool of herself.

If you're not a person who is naturally goofy or outgoing, it's also helpful to just take your time and not notice or care about her awkwardness or shy tendencies. Over time, she'll begin to feel better around you because her fears of not knowing what to say will go away. Being patient and not forcing her to talk will allow her to become confident and feel like what she has to say will be important.

Ask her questions. If you really like this girl, it's easy to just ask her questions about what she likes or what she thinks of things. This takes the pressure off of her so she's not worried about not knowing what to say.

This will also give her a point in the conversation where she knows it's okay to talk and where she knows you want to know what she thinks about something. Just be sure to not pester her with too many questions, especially if she seems to become more shy and withdrawn.

If you know what she's into, that's an easy way to start talking to her, especially if you both share a common interest, such as art or music.

Avoid Pointing Out That She's Shy or Doesn't Talk Much

One of the sure-fire ways to make a shy girl feel uncomfortable is to bring up how she's shy or mention how she's not talking. It might be frustrating at first, but by constantly pestering her and telling her how shy she is.

Among shy people, being called shy is one of the most irritating observations you can point out because shy people already know they are shy. Pointing it out just draws more attention to the fact.

Understand That Shy People Need Time to Be Alone

Chances are, if she's shy, she's an introvert, and she may need time to herself every once in a while to feel better. If she doesn't feel up to going to a big party with you, don't make her feel bad about it (chance are she'll beat herself up about it more than you will).

Getting over shyness and wanting to be a part of your life, in your social life, and hanging out with friends is going to be a huge change. Be supportive. If you push her too far, she may end up withdrawing from you and feel like she's not good enough or can't talk to people anymore.

What Is She Thinking?

When trying to know whether a girl is interested in you, a shy girl can be one of the trickiest to figure out. An easy way to know if she's into you is to see how she reacts over time to you.

If she starts to not be so shy around you, there's a good chance that she likes you. In order for her to consider dating you, she has to feel comfortable around you and want to spend time with you.

The first encounters will more or less be her thinking about how she doesn't know what to say. This can be really stressful as the more she feels like she can't talk or doesn't know how to keep you interested, the more pressure she'll feel and shyer she will get. This is why being goofy and making her laugh will help her feel more comfortable, as she will be able to not feel the pressure of having to talk.

As you continue to become her friend or show interest in her, she may begin to start wondering what you still are interested in liking her. Depending on what kind of shy girl she is, she may have never considered someone like you would like her. There may come a time when she'll bring this up with you.

It's important at this time to understand where she's coming from and not brush aside her feelings. Shy people often have a hard time dealing with and getting over being shy, so if she's willing to open up to you and share her feelings, be sure to listen and let her know that you don't care that she is shy.

How to Ask a Shy Girl Out

Depending on the girl, you may actually find that she is not as shy as you thought she was. In this case, you may be surprised when she asks you out herself or starts dropping hints about how she wants to spend more time with you.

If this doesn't happen with the particular girl you're interested in, or you become unable to stand not knowing if she would like to go out with you, you'll want to consider how best to ask her out.

Tips on Asking Her Out

  • Be sure to not have anyone around when you ask her. Having other people around when you ask will only pressure her and make her uncomfortable and shy.
  • If she's still shy around you and you think that talking to her will make her shy. You could consider writing her a note.
  • Keep it casual, and don't stretch it out. Avoid any long awkward build-ups to asking her.
  • Invite her out for ice cream, and judging from how she reacts, ask if she would like to be your girlfriend.
  • Wait for the right moment. There will usually come a time when it feels right to ask her out.
A first date with a shy girl is best done out of the public eye.

A first date with a shy girl is best done out of the public eye.

First Date(s) With a Shy Girl

Much like when you ask her out, it's a good idea to go somewhere where there's not a lot of people around or people she knows. Showing any form of affection, at least at first, in a public setting will probably make her a little shy and awkward.

The ideal first date would be somewhere where you can spend time alone, without the pressures of anyone around to make her feel more nervous. Going for a walk, a state park, or a quiet diner are all good ideas.

Also, be sure that the first time you two hold hands or kiss (again, this depends on how shy she still is) would probably be best if it happened with just the two of you around.

Do Not Move Too Fast

Moving too fast could cause her to become shy around you again, setting you both back in the relationship you were building. It's best to move slowly or ask if she's comfortable if you're unsure of whether or not she's ready for holding hands or going to a movie. (This is usually helpful in young relationships in middle school or high school where everyone is getting a feel for dating).

Again, it really depends on how shy the girl is and her reasons for being shy. She may open up to you quickly, or she may remain very shy with you for a long time. Be sure to keep in mind that this relationship will take a long time to develop. Communication is key.

If you move too fast, she may end up not knowing how to deal with the situation. This can lead to her avoiding you, not answering your phone calls, or lying about stupid things in order to try to keep you away. These are signs that you're going too fast or that she's not into you.

Final Thoughts and Advice

Dating a shy girl is not much different than dating any other girl, except for the fact that you'll have to spend a lot more time making sure she is comfortable and that you're not moving too fast.

The first few months or weeks (depending on the girl) will be slow until the girl starts opening up to you. After she does this, you'll soon find out more things about her and will probably figure out why she was so shy in the first place.

Just be sure to relieve any of the pressure she'll be feeling of overcoming her shyness and show her your support and love. This is key in dating a shy girl and maintaining that relationship. Be open with her and honest, and she'll do the same with you.

A quick note from personal experience: I've actually found that certain people just make you feel more comfortable than others. If holding someone's hand or being close to them causes either of you any discomfort or makes you nervous, you may want to consider if this is the right person for you.

I've had one boyfriend who I never could feel comfortable around (thankfully, it ended) and another boyfriend who I felt instantly comfortable around.

There's no point in forcing any relationship if you're not happy or comfortable with it. It may seem like a bad note to leave on, but there are "plenty of fish in the sea," and the one person who does make you feel comfortable and loved may just be out there waiting for you.