Why Dating and Marrying a Passive-Aggressive Man Is a Horrible Mistake
By the time my marriage to my passive aggressive husband came to an end I had no self-esteem...The loneliness I experienced in my marriage was worse than any I had ever felt as a single woman.— Cathy Meyer, certified divorce coach and marriage educator
A Passive-Aggressive Guy Withholds Communication, Making a Woman Go Crazy
If you're dating a passive-aggressive guy, ladies, don't think you have the power to change him no matter how motivated and in love you are. It will only end with you feeling frustrated, confused, and shell-shocked. When it's over, you'll be left in shambles, mourning a relationship that you never truly understood. A worse fate befalls you if you wind up marrying the man and get stuck in a hellhole of silent hostility and hushed retaliation.
Communication is the basis for any solid relationship and the passive-aggressive dude just doesn't have the goods even if he's basically a "nice man." We women types need a steady flow of talk back and forth and a passive-aggressive guy withholds that, causing us enormous distress and discomfort. His refusal to speak can be far more abusive to us in the long haul than a push or shove. Remember, ladies, the passive-aggressive man is far more hurtful in what he doesn't do than what he does do!
What Is Passive-Aggressive Behavior in Men?
When one thinks of passive-aggressive behavior in men, the image of a husband leaving the toilet seat up comes to mind. Yet, that innocuous example doesn't represent the deep psychological and emotional harm that many passive-aggressive behaviors cause. These behaviors express anger and retaliation in an “under the radar” manner. They include using sarcasm, procrastinating, complaining, playing the martyr, arriving late, sulking, and giving the silent treatment.
A Passive-Aggressive Guy Doesn't Want to Put in the Time and Effort It Takes for a Good Relationship
When it comes to the pitfalls of dating passive-aggressive men, I know of what I speak because I've watched my younger brother operate for over 50 years. He's the kind of guy casual observers dub laid back, mellow, and chill. They describe him as going with the flow and wonder why he's never been married because he's "such as catch." Yet, for those of us who know him better, he's the perennial bachelor who's ambivalent about being in a relationship, doesn't want to be controlled, and whose life is greatly restricted by his unresolved childhood pain.
As his sister, I see a man who's incapable of forming a meaningful relationship because he doesn't want to put in the time, energy, and communication it takes. He's too defensive and full of shame to appear vulnerable and show his feelings. As a member of the sisterhood of women, I wish I could get the name and number of every lady he's dated and let her know that it wasn't anything she did wrong; it was all him. Then I'd give her these five warning signs so she won't make the same foolish mistake again.
1. He Doesn't Listen.
While visiting my brother's house, I watch him hold the phone to his ear and “listen” to his girlfriend on the other end while simultaneously watching an NFL game. He makes the obligatory yes, no, and uh-huh sounds but barely takes in a thing she says. Hearing only a smidgen of this or that, his lack of active listening sets the stage for future misunderstandings in their relationship.
A man who isn't passive-aggressive would deal with the situation in a direct way, telling his girlfriend not to call during sporting events. A passive-aggressive dude such as my brother, though, plays the part of “Mr. Nice Guy” by being on the phone while secretly seething that his viewing time has been disrupted. He gets his revenge on her by only pretending to listen. While my brother uses TV as his tool of avoidance, other passive-aggressive men use their cell phones, computers, and newspapers.
2. He Gives the Silent Treatment.
I'll never forget the day of my son's baptism when we invited family and friends to the church followed by a reception at our home. My brother brought his girlfriend and, as I found out later, the two had been arguing about moving in together and now he was giving her the silent treatment. In addition to making it an awkward day for all of us, I realized how petty and childish my brother was—how totally unprepared he was for a mature relationship.
According to psychology professor, Kip Williams, the effects of a man's silence can be both emotionally and physically devastating to his partner. It can make her feel alone, ostracized, and unworthy. This, in turn, can lead to a decrease in self-esteem and an increase in depression and stress. It can make her feel that she's losing control of her life.
Having grown up in the same dysfunctional home as my brother where feelings got squelched and communication skills were limp, I feel tremendous compassion for him. Our mother gave our father the silent treatment on a regular basis when we were kids, sometimes leaving our house for hours without saying where she was going and when she'd come back. We grew up thinking that was normal. We didn't have role models who spoke about their feelings in a calm, honest, and productive manner.
They’re typically raised in families where it’s not safe to express anger—they’re never taught to communicate it in a healthy manner. They adapt by channeling these feelings into other less obvious behaviors; this gives them a sense of power and control. They’re masters at shirking responsibility by hurting you in ways that appear unintentional or unavoidable. Passive aggressive people operate by stuffing anger, being accommodating, and then indirectly sticking it to you.— Judith Orloff, psychiatrist and author
3. He's Always Late.
Some people think individuals such as my brother, who are always running late, do so to flaunt their superiority. However, psychotherapist, Michael Formica, believes the opposite is true. He writes: "The chronically tardy, in large measure, have a perception that others do not feel them to be important, so they operate in a way so as to impose themselves on a situation—exerting control to feel in control—while in reality they are silently validating their own sense of unworthiness, whether consciously or unconsciously."
These words certainly ring true to me. My brother and I grew up in a home where we weren't made to feel valued and we often felt invisible. As adults, we both struggle with low self-esteem and often avoid social occasions. When my brother arrives late for a date, it's not a reflection of his arrogance but of his extreme apprehension.
Because you can’t have an honest, direct conversation with a passive-aggressive partner, nothing ever gets resolved. They say yes, and then their behavior screams NO.— Darlene Lancer, marriage and family therapist
4. He Fears Open Communication.
Young straight-shooting people today probably can't appreciate that many of us were taught that such directness was rude when we were kids. My brother and I grew up in the 1970's in a strict religious home and attended Catholic schools where the nuns ruled with an iron fist. We were never encouraged to speak openly and honestly with our parents or other adults. The phrase "little children should be seen and not heard" was the philosophy in our home. My brother and I learned at a young age to hide our thoughts and feelings, protecting our mom and dad from anything they might find “distasteful.”
With his girlfriends, my brother duplicates the mother-son dynamic that began decades ago. He withholds important information about who he is and how he feels. He never risks exposing his true self, fearing disapproval and rejection, no matter how many hours he spends with a woman. The more she pushes him to open up, the more he shuts down.
5. He Procrastinates.
If you were to visit the home my brother shares with his girlfriend, you'd see a large deck off their living room covered with yellow caution tape and a sign that reads: “Unsafe. Keep off!” It's been like this way for almost four years with little chance repairs will happen any time soon. While it may be a difficult and expensive fix for many home owners, it isn't for my brother; he's an architect and structural engineer!
His expertise, though, doesn't matter in this situation. He won't get around to fixing the deck because he's fuming inside about things his girlfriend has done—bringing home a stray cat, buying an expensive piano, and inviting her girlfriend to stay with them for a month. He's been stockpiling these hurts for years and now he's quietly exacting his revenge. His poor girlfriend, however, doesn't understand what's happening!
I love my brother and, in many ways, he's indeed the “good guy” that casual acquaintances see. He's also heavily flawed. I'd never want to be married to him nor would I ever set up one of my friends with him. This is especially true of any pal of mine who hopes to have kids some day. My brother's inability to speak his mind would cause huge problems in any family.
While some view passive-aggressive types as vicious, I have a different perspective having grown up with one. I know my brother is a product of his environment—someone still battling internally with our overbearing mother. He had to give up a lot of control to her as a kid and he doesn't want to do that with another woman. He wants to avoid confrontation at any cost so cutting off communication has become his lifelong habit. So, ladies, don't think you can fix a passive-aggressive man and don't think you'll enjoy his "easy-going" ways. Run, don't walk, away or you'll be faced with a world of frustration and hurt.
If You Must Interact With a Passive-Aggressive Guy, This Book Gives Outstanding Advice on How to Do It Effectively
While we women have the power to not date and marry a passive-aggressive guy, we don't have the ability to avoid them all together. We might have one who's a brother like I do or a boss, a co-worker, a father-in-law, or a neighbor. In this thought-provoking book, clinical psychologist, Scott Wetzler, gives invaluable advice for dealing with a passive-aggressive man when you must. If you're like me, you'll be nodding your head in recognition and agreement on every page. If you have a friend who's dating a passive-aggressive guy, give her this book as a present. She may not thank you at first but will be eternally grateful in the future!
Questions & Answers
© 2017 McKenna Meyers